“We conquered a small universe in a short amount of time,” says Constance Neely, reflecting on the achievements of a workshop which she helped to organize in Nairobi, in October 2014. “In just two days, we reviewed over 40 Kenyan climate-smart agriculture projects, and we came up with some coherent technical and policy messages.”
The original idea was to organize a workshop to review the achievements of the Mitigation of Climate Change in Agriculture (MICCA) project. However, Constance, who divides her time between the World Agroforestry Centre and the UN Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO), decided that it would make more sense to involve as many people as possible, from as many different initiatives, in a climate-smart workshop.
Participants at the workshop, which was convened by FAO, the World Agroforestry Centre, the Research Program on Climate Change, Agriculture and Food Security (CCAFS) and the Climate Change Unit of Kenya’s Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Fisheries, included scientists, farmers, development practitioners and policy makers. They shared and analysed scientific evidence and field experience from 44 projects in working groups which focused on climate information and insurance, cropping systems, livestock and aquaculture, energy, conservation agriculture and agroforestry, climate-smart agriculture and gender, farmer adoption, advisory and capacity development, and markets and microfinance.
“Each group discussed what made projects work, explored how to build capacity and came up with a clear set of messages,” says Sabrina Chesterman, lead author with Constance of the technical workshop document, which has been published as a CCAFS Working Paper: Evidence and Policy Implications of Climate Smart Agriculture in Kenya.
This highlights an array of different climatesmart practices which are currently being adopted by Kenyan farmers, including agroforestry, conservation agriculture, integrated crop production systems and efficient grazing practices. These are designed to help farmers increase food production, become more resilient to climate change and reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
“The process used was as important as the technical material,” says Constance. “When the stakeholders interact with the evidence and experiences based on their desired outcome, the commonalities and tensions emerge and lessons learned are steadily forged.”
The policy messages outlined in the working paper were subsequently used in the revision of Kenya’s 2014 Draft National Climate Change Policy Framework. A policy brief – Transitioning Towards Climate Smart Agriculture in Kenya: Linking Research, Practice and Policy – introduced the policy messages to a wider audience. It was launched at the UN Climate Change Meeting (COP 20) in Peru in December 2014.
Here, in brief, are the key messages:
- Climate-smart agriculture should contribute to building opportunities for employment, education and commerce. It is smart precisely because it addresses a range of key development issues.
- Research, agricultural activities and policy development should be integrated from the outset. This will help to improve decision-making at all levels.
- Integrating the production of livestock, fish, crops and trees on farms or throughout the landscape can enhance productivity, strengthen the resilience of farming systems and reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
- Specific attention should be paid to building the capacity of women and young people who manage natural resources.
- It is important to connect policies to regulations, as inconsistencies between the two can undermine climate-smart agriculture.
- Climate-smart agriculture still faces a number of knowledge gaps, such as the lack of baseline data for measuring, reporting and verifying the effectiveness of climate-smart agriculture
Gathering evidence for climate-smart agriculture
Launched by FAO in 2011, the Mitigation of Climate Change in Agriculture (MICCA) project measured the performance of different agricultural systems in terms of food production, reducing greenhouse gas emissions and helping farmers adapt to climate change. The World Agroforestry Centre was responsible for managing the pilot projects in Kenya and Tanzania.
In Kenya, agroecologist Todd Rosenstock and his team worked with the East Africa Dairy Development Project (EADD), assessing different types of smallholder dairy production systems. In Tanzania, they worked with CARE International, which was encouraging farmers to adopt conservation agriculture on steep hillsides. The research gained important insights into what sort of climate-smart agricultural practices work best. This was one of the 44 projects presented at the climate-smart agriculture workshop held in Nairobi in October 2014.
During the course of the project, over 4600 farmers attended training sessions on climate-smart agricultural practices in Kaptumo, Kenya. This translates into many thousands more farmers reached, thanks to the innovative farmer-to-farmer extension approach. Based on previous research, the World Agroforestry Centre estimates that each farmer-trainer engages approximately 20 additional farmers.
In Tanzania, nearly 3000 farmers were trained in the four practices that made up the menu of climate-smart agricultural practices, including conservation agriculture, improved cooking stoves, soil and water conservation and agroforestry. CARE reported a significant difference in food security for those implementing the MICCA climate-smart interventions in Kolero, Tanzania.
The project also had a significant impact on some of the partners’ activities. For example, the East African Dairy Development project’s adoption of climate-smart agriculture concepts has been influenced by its relationship with MICCA. This suggests that MICCA achieved one of its main goals, which was to mainstream climate-smart agriculture into regional development activities.
Research by MICCA on which climate-smart practices work best has also stimulated the World Agroforestry Centre to carry out further research on the subject. In January 2015, the Centre launched a new 4-year CCAFS-funded project, ‘Partnerships for scaling climate-smart agriculture.’ This supports the implementation of climate-smart agriculture across sub-Saharan Africa by governments and development partners.
Reference
Transitioning Towards Climate Smart Agriculture in Kenya: Linking Research, Practice and Policy. 2015, FAO